| Plains (7 variants) | 99 |
| Plains (7 variants) | 100 |
| Planar Atlas (7 variants) | 51 |
| Plundering Predator (7 variants) | 37 |
| Pounce (7 variants) | 707 |
| Pouncing Lynx (7 variants) | 228 |
| Predator's Howl (7 variants) | 708 |
| Preordain (7 variants) | 63 |
| Presence of Gond (7 variants) | 709 |
| Press for Answers (7 variants) | 337 |
| Preston, the Vanisher (7 variants) | 8 |
| Prey Upon (7 variants) | 710 |
| Prickly Marmoset (7 variants) | 580 |
| Pridemalkin (7 variants) | 711 |
| Priest of the Blood Rite (7 variants) | 457 |
| Primeval Herald (7 variants) | 42 |
| Primordial Hydra (7 variants) | 712 |
| Professional Face-Breaker (7 variants) | 581 |
| Prowling Felidar (7 variants) | 229 |
| Prowling Serpopard (7 variants) | 713 |
| Psychosis Crawler (7 variants) | 792 |
| Pyre-Sledge Arsonist (7 variants) | 582 |
| Quakefoot Cyclops (7 variants) | 583 |
| Quarry Beetle (7 variants) | 714 |
| Radiant's Judgment (7 variants) | 230 |
| Raiders' Karve (7 variants) | 793 |
| Raking Claws (7 variants) | 584 |
| Ram Through (7 variants) | 91 |
| Rambunctious Mutt (7 variants) | 231 |
| Rampaging Baloths (7 variants) | 715 |
| Rampaging Growth (7 variants) | 43 |
| Rapacious Dragon (7 variants) | 80 |
| Ravenous Giant (7 variants) | 585 |
| Raze the Effigy (7 variants) | 586 |
| Reaper from the Abyss (7 variants) | 458 |
| Reassembling Skeleton (7 variants) | 125 |
| Reave Soul (7 variants) | 459 |
| Reckless Amplimancer (7 variants) | 716 |
| Reckless Fireweaver (7 variants) | 587 |
| Reclamation Sage (7 variants) | 717 |
| Regal Caracal (7 variants) | 232 |
| Relentless Pursuit (7 variants) | 718 |
| Renegade Demon (7 variants) | 126 |
| Renowned Weaponsmith (7 variants) | 338 |
| Reptilian Reflection (7 variants) | 588 |
| Restoration Angel (7 variants) | 233 |
| Returned Reveler (7 variants) | 460 |
| Revenant (7 variants) | 461 |
| Rhonas the Indomitable (7 variants) | 719 |
| Rhystic Study (7 variants) | 114 |