| Shadows Over Innistrad Checklist 2 | CH2 |
| Shadows Over Innistrad Checklist 1 | CH1 |
| Arlinn, Embraced by the Moon Emblem | 18 |
| Jace, Unraveler of Secrets Emblem | 17 |
| Clue | 16 |
| Clue | 15 |
| Clue | 14 |
| Clue | 13 |
| Clue | 12 |
| Clue | 11 |
| Human Cleric | 10 |
| Wolf | 9 |
| Ooze | 8 |
| Insect | 7 |
| Devil | 6 |
| Zombie | 5 |
| Vampire Knight | 4 |
| Spirit | 3 |
| Human Soldier | 2 |
| Angel | 1 |