| Path to Exile (14 variants) | 49 |
| Pathrazer of Ulamog (14 variants) | 4 |
| Pearl Medallion (7 variants) | 612 |
| Pearl Medallion (12 variants) | 401 |
| Perilous Vault (4 variants) | 968 |
| Personal Tutor (14 variants) | 633 |
| Personal Tutor (7 variants) | 493 |
| Personal Tutor (14 variants) | 110 |
| Phyrexian Gargantua (14 variants) | 178 |
| Phyrexian Ingester (14 variants) | 111 |
| Phyrexian Triniform (4 variants) | 969 |
| Pianna, Nomad Captain (14 variants) | 50 |
| Pilgrim's Eye (12 variants) | 402 |
| Pillar of Origins (4 variants) | 970 |
| Plains (14 variants) | 438 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 783 |
| Plains (14 variants) | 439 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 784 |
| Plains (14 variants) | 437 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 785 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 786 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 787 |
| Pollenbright Druid (12 variants) | 312 |
| Port Town (4 variants) | 1019 |
| Portal Mage (14 variants) | 112 |
| Prairie Stream (4 variants) | 1020 |
| Predatory Rampage (12 variants) | 313 |
| Priest of the Blood Rite (14 variants) | 179 |
| Prismatic Lens (12 variants) | 403 |
| Promise of Loyalty (4 variants) | 833 |
| Prophetic Prism (12 variants) | 404 |
| Puresteel Paladin (14 variants) | 627 |
| Puresteel Paladin (14 variants) | 51 |
| Puresteel Paladin (7 variants) | 469 |
| Purphoros, God of the Forge (12 variants) | 246 |
| Purphoros, God of the Forge (7 variants) | 547 |
| Queen Marchesa (12 variants) | 350 |
| Queen Marchesa (7 variants) | 588 |
| Quick Sliver (4 variants) | 907 |
| Raff Capashen, Ship's Mage (12 variants) | 351 |
| Rafiq of the Many (12 variants) | 352 |
| Rafiq of the Many (7 variants) | 589 |
| Rakka Mar (12 variants) | 247 |
| Ram Through (12 variants) | 314 |
| Rampaging Brontodon (12 variants) | 315 |
| Rampant Growth (4 variants) | 908 |
| Rankle, Master of Pranks (14 variants) | 180 |
| Rankle, Master of Pranks (7 variants) | 519 |
| Rapacious Dragon (12 variants) | 248 |
| Rapacious One (12 variants) | 249 |