| Skyline Despot (12 variants) | 254 |
| Skyshroud Claim (12 variants) | 321 |
| Skysnare Spider (12 variants) | 322 |
| Slice and Dice (12 variants) | 255 |
| Slimefoot, the Stowaway (12 variants) | 356 |
| Slimefoot, the Stowaway (14 variants) | 686 |
| Sliver Gravemother (10 variants) | 777 |
| Sliver Gravemother (4 variants) | 707 |
| Sliver Gravemother (4 variants) | 782 |
| Sliver Hivelord (4 variants) | 937 |
| Smoldering Marsh (4 variants) | 1036 |
| Smothering Tithe (14 variants) | 57 |
| Smothering Tithe (14 variants) | 693 |
| Smothering Tithe (7 variants) | 473 |
| Snakeskin Veil (12 variants) | 323 |
| Sol Ring (12 variants) | 410 |
| Sol Ring (14 variants) | 703 |
| Solemn Simulacrum (4 variants) | 973 |
| Song of the Dryads (12 variants) | 324 |
| Song of the Dryads (7 variants) | 572 |
| Soul of New Phyrexia (4 variants) | 974 |
| Sower of Discord (14 variants) | 187 |
| Sower of Discord (7 variants) | 522 |
| Spark Double (4 variants) | 856 |
| Sparkshaper Visionary (10 variants) | 758 |
| Sparkshaper Visionary (4 variants) | 726 |
| Spatial Contortion (4 variants) | 809 |
| Spectator Seating (12 variants) | 427 |
| Spectator Seating (7 variants) | 618 |
| Spectator Seating (14 variants) | 664 |
| Spectral Grasp (14 variants) | 58 |
| Spectral Searchlight (12 variants) | 411 |
| Spellseeker (14 variants) | 120 |
| Spellseeker (7 variants) | 495 |
| Spellseeker (14 variants) | 635 |
| Spikeshot Goblin (12 variants) | 256 |
| Spirited Companion (4 variants) | 838 |
| Spitebellows (12 variants) | 257 |
| Spiteful Sliver (4 variants) | 881 |
| Squee, Goblin Nabob (12 variants) | 258 |
| Star of Extinction (7 variants) | 550 |
| Star of Extinction (12 variants) | 259 |
| Starfield Mystic (4 variants) | 839 |
| Starfield of Nyx (4 variants) | 840 |
| Staunch Throneguard (12 variants) | 412 |
| Steel Hellkite (4 variants) | 975 |
| Steelshaper's Gift (14 variants) | 629 |
| Steelshaper's Gift (14 variants) | 59 |
| Steelshaper's Gift (7 variants) | 474 |
| Stitcher Geralf (7 variants) | 496 |