| Herald of the Pantheon (4 variants) | 898 |
| Herald's Horn (4 variants) | 953 |
| Hero's Blade (12 variants) | 391 |
| Heroic Intervention (12 variants) | 295 |
| Heroic Intervention (7 variants) | 563 |
| Hibernation Sliver (4 variants) | 925 |
| Hoarding Dragon (12 variants) | 233 |
| Hollowhead Sliver (4 variants) | 878 |
| Honor-Worn Shaku (4 variants) | 954 |
| Hunter's Insight (12 variants) | 296 |
| Icon of Ancestry (4 variants) | 955 |
| Idol of Oblivion (12 variants) | 392 |
| Idol of Oblivion (7 variants) | 607 |
| Ilysian Caryatid (12 variants) | 297 |
| Imp's Mischief (14 variants) | 167 |
| Imp's Mischief (7 variants) | 514 |
| Impulsive Pilferer (12 variants) | 234 |
| Inferno Titan (12 variants) | 235 |
| Inferno Titan (7 variants) | 541 |
| Inga Rune-Eyes (14 variants) | 100 |
| Inspiring Statuary (12 variants) | 394 |
| Inspiring Statuary (7 variants) | 609 |
| Insurrection (12 variants) | 236 |
| Insurrection (14 variants) | 699 |
| Insurrection (7 variants) | 542 |
| Intangible Virtue (14 variants) | 31 |
| Interplanar Beacon (4 variants) | 1004 |
| Investigator's Journal (4 variants) | 956 |
| Irrigated Farmland (4 variants) | 1005 |
| Isareth the Awakener (14 variants) | 168 |
| Island (4 variants) | 788 |
| Island (4 variants) | 789 |
| Island (14 variants) | 441 |
| Island (14 variants) | 442 |
| Island (4 variants) | 790 |
| Island (14 variants) | 440 |
| It That Betrays (4 variants) | 805 |
| Izzet Signet (4 variants) | 957 |
| Jace Beleren (4 variants) | 850 |
| Jace, Architect of Thought (4 variants) | 851 |
| Jace, Mirror Mage (4 variants) | 852 |
| Jade Mage (12 variants) | 298 |
| Jaya's Phoenix (4 variants) | 738 |
| Jaya's Phoenix (10 variants) | 768 |
| Jazal Goldmane (7 variants) | 463 |
| Jazal Goldmane (14 variants) | 32 |
| Jet Medallion (7 variants) | 610 |
| Jet Medallion (12 variants) | 395 |
| Jeweled Lotus (14 variants) | 702 |
| Jeweled Lotus (12 variants) | 396 |