| Plains (4 variants) | 785 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 786 |
| Plains (4 variants) | 787 |
| Pillar of Origins (4 variants) | 970 |
| Pilgrim's Eye (12 variants) | 402 |
| Pianna, Nomad Captain (14 variants) | 50 |
| Phyrexian Triniform (4 variants) | 969 |
| Phyrexian Ingester (14 variants) | 111 |
| Phyrexian Gargantua (14 variants) | 178 |
| Personal Tutor (14 variants) | 633 |
| Personal Tutor (7 variants) | 493 |
| Personal Tutor (14 variants) | 110 |
| Perilous Vault (4 variants) | 968 |
| Pearl Medallion (7 variants) | 612 |
| Pearl Medallion (12 variants) | 401 |
| Pathrazer of Ulamog (14 variants) | 4 |
| Path to Exile (14 variants) | 626 |
| Path to Exile (14 variants) | 49 |
| Path of Ancestry (14 variants) | 661 |
| Path of Ancestry (12 variants) | 423 |
| Palladium Myr (4 variants) | 967 |
| Palace Sentinels (14 variants) | 48 |
| Palace Jailer (14 variants) | 47 |
| Padeem, Consul of Innovation (14 variants) | 109 |
| Oviya Pashiri, Sage Lifecrafter (12 variants) | 311 |
| Orzhov Basilica (4 variants) | 1018 |
| Ornithopter of Paradise (4 variants) | 966 |
| Oreskos Explorer (4 variants) | 832 |
| Opulent Palace (4 variants) | 1017 |
| Opal Palace (12 variants) | 422 |
| Ondu Spiritdancer (4 variants) | 723 |
| Ondu Spiritdancer (10 variants) | 756 |
| Onakke Oathkeeper (4 variants) | 722 |
| Onakke Oathkeeper (10 variants) | 755 |
| Omnath, Locus of Mana (7 variants) | 568 |
| Omnath, Locus of Mana (5 variants) | 1063 |
| Omnath, Locus of Mana (12 variants) | 310 |
| Omnath, Locus of Mana (14 variants) | 680 |
| Omen of the Sun (4 variants) | 831 |
| Omen of the Hunt (4 variants) | 906 |
| Omarthis, Ghostfire Initiate (4 variants) | 708 |
| Omarthis, Ghostfire Initiate (10 variants) | 748 |
| Ohran Frostfang (14 variants) | 650 |
| Ohran Frostfang (7 variants) | 567 |
| Ohran Frostfang (12 variants) | 309 |
| Ogre Slumlord (14 variants) | 177 |
| Ogre Slumlord (7 variants) | 518 |
| Odric, Master Tactician (14 variants) | 46 |
| Odric, Master Tactician (7 variants) | 468 |
| Obscuring Haze (14 variants) | 701 |