| Pantlaza, Sun-Favored (16 variants) | 4 |
| Paleontologist's Pick-Axe // Dinosaur Headdress (2 variants) | 16 |
| Paleontologist's Pick-Axe // Dinosaur Headdress (2 variants) | 36 |
| Pact of the Serpent (7 variants) | 206 |
| Otepec Huntmaster (7 variants) | 229 |
| Orzhov Signet (7 variants) | 310 |
| Orzhov Basilica (7 variants) | 345 |
| Ore-Rich Stalactite // Cosmium Catalyst (2 variants) | 11 |
| Ore-Rich Stalactite // Cosmium Catalyst (2 variants) | 23 |
| Order of Sacred Dusk (7 variants) | 97 |
| Order of Sacred Dusk (5 variants) | 65 |
| Olivia's Wrath (7 variants) | 205 |
| Oathsworn Vampire (7 variants) | 204 |
| Nighthawk Scavenger (7 variants) | 203 |
| New Blood (7 variants) | 202 |
| Nephalia Drownyard (7 variants) | 344 |
| Myriad Landscape (7 variants) | 343 |
| Mosswort Bridge (7 variants) | 342 |
| Mist Dancer (7 variants) | 76 |
| Mist Dancer (5 variants) | 44 |
| Mind Stone (7 variants) | 309 |
| Mimic Vat (16 variants) | 115 |
| Migration Path (7 variants) | 246 |
| Metallic Mimic (7 variants) | 308 |
| Merrow Reejerey (7 variants) | 165 |
| Merfolk Sovereign (7 variants) | 164 |
| Merfolk Skydiver (7 variants) | 277 |
| Merfolk Mistbinder (7 variants) | 276 |
| Merchant Raiders (7 variants) | 163 |
| Mavren Fein, Dusk Apostle (7 variants) | 133 |
| Master of the Pearl Trident (7 variants) | 162 |
| Master of Dark Rites (7 variants) | 83 |
| Master of Dark Rites (5 variants) | 51 |
| Martyr of Dusk (7 variants) | 132 |
| March of the Canonized (5 variants) | 41 |
| March of the Canonized (7 variants) | 73 |
| Marauding Raptor (7 variants) | 228 |
| Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator (7 variants) | 161 |
| Majestic Heliopterus (7 variants) | 131 |
| Llanowar Reborn (7 variants) | 341 |
| Lightning Greaves (16 variants) | 114 |
| Lifecrafter's Bestiary (7 variants) | 307 |
| Lethal Scheme (7 variants) | 201 |
| Legion Lieutenant (7 variants) | 275 |
| Kumena, Tyrant of Orazca (7 variants) | 274 |
| Kopala, Warden of Waves (7 variants) | 160 |
| Kodama's Reach (7 variants) | 245 |
| Kiora's Follower (7 variants) | 273 |
| Kinjalli's Sunwing (7 variants) | 130 |
| King Narfi's Betrayal (7 variants) | 272 |