| Always Watching | 1s |
| Angel of Deliverance | 2 |
| Angel of Deliverance | 2s |
| Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier | 5s |
| Bygone Bishop | 8s |
| Declaration in Stone | 12s |
| Descend upon the Sinful | 13s |
| Drogskol Cavalry | 15 |
| Drogskol Cavalry | 15s |
| Eerie Interlude (2 variants) | 16p |
| Eerie Interlude | 16s |
| Hanweir Militia Captain // Westvale Cult Leader | 21s |
| Odric, Lunarch Marshal | 31s |
| Thalia's Lieutenant | 43s |
| Confirm Suspicions | 53s |
| Engulf the Shore | 58s |
| Epiphany at the Drownyard | 59s |
| Forgotten Creation | 63s |
| Geralf's Masterpiece | 65s |
| Jace, Unraveler of Secrets | 69s |
| Nephalia Moondrakes | 75 |
| Nephalia Moondrakes | 75s |
| Rattlechains | 81s |
| Startled Awake // Persistent Nightmare | 88s |
| Thing in the Ice // Awoken Horror | 92s |
| Welcome to the Fold | 96s |
| Asylum Visitor | 99s |
| Behold the Beyond | 101s |
| Diregraf Colossus | 107s |
| Elusive Tormentor // Insidious Mist | 108 |
| Elusive Tormentor // Insidious Mist | 108s |
| Ever After | 109s |
| From Under the Floorboards | 111s |
| Markov Dreadknight | 122 |
| Markov Dreadknight | 122s |
| Mindwrack Demon | 124s |
| Relentless Dead | 131s |
| To the Slaughter | 139s |
| Triskaidekaphobia | 141s |
| Avacyn's Judgment | 145s |
| Burn from Within | 148s |
| Devils' Playground | 151s |
| Falkenrath Gorger | 155s |
| Flameblade Angel | 157 |
| Flameblade Angel | 157s |
| Geier Reach Bandit // Vildin-Pack Alpha | 159s |
| Goldnight Castigator | 162s |
| Harness the Storm | 163s |
| Incorrigible Youths | 166 |
| Ravenous Bloodseeker | 175 |