| Cheer | 25 |
| Eggnogger's 'Stache | 24 |
| Seasonal Sequels | 23 |
| Chaos Wrap | 22 |
| Treasure | 21★ |
| Last-Minute Chopping | 21 |
| Topdeck the Halls | 20 |
| Decorated Knight // Present Arms | 19 |
| Bog Humbugs | 18 |
| Some Disassembly Required | 17 |
| Thopter Pie Network | 16 |
| Goblin Sleigh Ride | 15 |
| Mishra's Toy Workshop | 14 |
| Stocking Tiger | 13† |
| Stocking Tiger | 13 |
| Naughty // Nice | 12 |
| Yule Ooze | 11 |
| Snow Mercy | 10 |
| Season's Beatings | 9 |
| Evil Presents | 8 |
| Gifts Given | 7† |
| Gifts Given | 7 |
| Fruitcake Elemental | 6 |