| Prize Pig (8 variants) | 43 |
| Pristine Talisman (7 variants) | 283 |
| Preordain (7 variants) | 196 |
| Prairie Stream (7 variants) | 324 |
| Port Town (7 variants) | 323 |
| Plea for Power (7 variants) | 195 |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard (8 variants) | 65 |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard (2 variants) | 472 |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard (5 variants) | 146 |
| Pillar of the Paruns | 402 |
| Pillar of the Paruns | 402z |
| Pillar of the Paruns (2 variants) | 372 |
| Path to Exile (7 variants) | 175 |
| Path of Ancestry (7 variants) | 322 |
| Paradise Druid (7 variants) | 255 |
| Palace Jailer (7 variants) | 174 |
| Pact of Negation (2 variants) | 523 |
| Overwhelming Stampede (7 variants) | 254 |
| Orcish Siegemaster (5 variants) | 116 |
| Orcish Siegemaster (8 variants) | 33 |
| Orcish Siegemaster (2 variants) | 435 |
| Orchard Strider (7 variants) | 253 |
| Opt (7 variants) | 194 |
| Olórin's Searing Light (2 variants) | 503 |
| Olórin's Searing Light | 547 |
| Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit (8 variants) | 17 |
| Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit (2 variants) | 419 |
| Oboro, Palace in the Clouds | 401 |
| Oboro, Palace in the Clouds (2 variants) | 371 |
| Oboro, Palace in the Clouds | 401z |
| Oath of Eorl (8 variants) | 64 |
| Oath of Eorl (2 variants) | 471 |
| Notion Thief (7 variants) | 270 |
| Night's Whisper (7 variants) | 205 |
| Necroblossom Snarl (7 variants) | 321 |
| Nazgûl Battle-Mace | 554 |
| Nazgûl Battle-Mace (2 variants) | 510 |
| Mystic Confluence (7 variants) | 193 |
| Myriad Landscape (2 variants) | 534 |
| Murmuring Bosk (7 variants) | 320 |
| Mouth of Ronom | 400 |
| Mouth of Ronom (2 variants) | 370 |
| Mouth of Ronom | 400z |
| Motivated Pony (5 variants) | 125 |
| Motivated Pony (8 variants) | 42 |
| Motivated Pony (2 variants) | 444 |
| Mortify (7 variants) | 269 |
| Moria Scavenger (8 variants) | 63 |
| Moria Scavenger (2 variants) | 470 |
| Moria Scavenger (5 variants) | 145 |