| Prodigal Pyromancer (18 variants) | 221 |
| Primal Rage (9 variants) | 286 |
| Primal Rage | 286★ |
| Platinum Angel (9 variants) | 339 |
| Platinum Angel | 339★ |
| Plains (18 variants) | 366 |
| Plains (16 variants) | 364 |
| Plains (18 variants) | 365 |
| Plains (18 variants) | 367 |
| Plague Wind (18 variants) | 169 |
| Plague Beetle | 168★ |
| Plague Beetle (9 variants) | 168 |
| Plagiarize (18 variants) | 97 |
| Pithing Needle (18 variants) | 338 |
| Pincher Beetles | 285★ |
| Pincher Beetles (9 variants) | 285 |
| Phyrexian Vault (18 variants) | 337 |
| Phyrexian Rager (18 variants) | 167 |
| Phantom Warrior (18 variants) | 96 |
| Phage the Untouchable (18 variants) | 166 |
| Persuasion | 95★ |
| Persuasion (9 variants) | 95 |
| Peek (18 variants) | 94 |
| Pariah | 33★ |
| Pariah (9 variants) | 33 |
| Paladin en-Vec (9 variants) | 32 |
| Paladin en-Vec | 32★ |
| Pacifism | 31★ |
| Pacifism (9 variants) | 31 |
| Overrun | 284★ |
| Overrun (9 variants) | 284 |
| Overgrowth | 283★ |
| Overgrowth (9 variants) | 283 |
| Ornithopter (9 variants) | 336 |
| Ornithopter | 336★ |
| Orcish Artillery (18 variants) | 220 |
| Nomad Mythmaker | 30★ |
| Nomad Mythmaker (9 variants) | 30 |
| No Rest for the Wicked (18 variants) | 165 |
| Nightmare (9 variants) | 164 |
| Nightmare | 164★ |
| Nekrataal (9 variants) | 163 |
| Nekrataal | 163★ |
| Naturalize (18 variants) | 282 |
| Natural Spring (18 variants) | 281 |
| Nantuko Husk (18 variants) | 162 |
| Mountain (2 variants) | 377 |
| Mountain (14 variants) | 376 |
| Mountain (2 variants) | 379 |
| Mountain (2 variants) | 378 |