| Queen Marchesa (9 variants) | 531 |
| Prying Eyes (18 variants) | 86 |
| Prossh, Skyraider of Kher (9 variants) | 530 |
| Prosperous Pirates (18 variants) | 85 |
| Prophetic Prism (18 variants) | 334 |
| Promise of Tomorrow (8 variants) | 622 |
| Promise of Tomorrow (18 variants) | 39 |
| Profane Transfusion (8 variants) | 653 |
| Profane Transfusion (18 variants) | 145 |
| Pride of the Perfect (18 variants) | 144 |
| Preordain (8 variants) | 640 |
| Preordain (18 variants) | 84 |
| Prava of the Steel Legion (18 variants) | 38 |
| Prava of the Steel Legion (9 variants) | 552 |
| Portent of Betrayal (18 variants) | 194 |
| Port Razer (18 variants) | 193 |
| Port Razer (8 variants) | 669 |
| Plains (10 variants) | 505 |
| Plains (10 variants) | 504 |
| Plague Reaver (18 variants) | 143 |
| Plague Reaver (8 variants) | 652 |
| Pirate's Cutlass (18 variants) | 333 |
| Pilgrim's Eye (18 variants) | 332 |
| Phyrexian Triniform (18 variants) | 331 |
| Phyrexian Triniform (8 variants) | 697 |
| Phyrexian Rager (18 variants) | 142 |
| Perilous Myr (18 variants) | 330 |
| Pennon Blade (18 variants) | 329 |
| Peel from Reality (19 variants) | 402 |
| Patron of the Valiant (18 variants) | 37 |
| Path of Ancestry (18 variants) | 353 |
| Path of Ancestry (8 variants) | 708 |
| Palace Sentinels (18 variants) | 36 |
| Orzhov Advokist (18 variants) | 35 |
| Oreskos Explorer (19 variants) | 381 |
| Ordeal of Nylea (18 variants) | 247 |
| Opposition Agent (18 variants) | 141 |
| Opposition Agent (8 variants) | 651 |
| Open the Armory (18 variants) | 34 |
| Opal Palace (8 variants) | 707 |
| Opal Palace (18 variants) | 352 |
| On Serra's Wings (19 variants) | 380 |
| Omenspeaker (18 variants) | 83 |
| Odric, Lunarch Marshal (19 variants) | 379 |
| Obeka, Brute Chronologist (9 variants) | 609 |
| Obeka, Brute Chronologist (18 variants) | 289 |
| Nymris, Oona's Trickster (18 variants) | 288 |
| Nymris, Oona's Trickster (9 variants) | 608 |
| Numa, Joraga Chieftain (9 variants) | 583 |
| Numa, Joraga Chieftain (18 variants) | 246 |