| Prime Speaker Zegana | 664 |
| Primal Might | 766 |
| Primal Might | 643 |
| Prideful Parent (12 variants) | 21 |
| Preposterous Proportions (12 variants) | 338 |
| Preposterous Proportions (12 variants) | 109 |
| Preposterous Proportions | 400 |
| Preposterous Proportions (8 variants) | 472 |
| Predator Ooze | 642 |
| Prayer of Binding | 739 |
| Prayer of Binding (6 variants) | 502 |
| Plains (12 variants) | 283 |
| Plains (12 variants) | 272 |
| Plains (12 variants) | 282 |
| Plains (12 variants) | 273 |
| Pirate's Cutlass (6 variants) | 563 |
| Pilfer (12 variants) | 181 |
| Phyrexian Arena (12 variants) | 180 |
| Phyrexian Arena (12 variants) | 322 |
| Phyrexian Arena (3 variants) | 728 |
| Phyrexian Arena | 386 |
| Perforating Artist (12 variants) | 124 |
| Pelakka Wurm | 720 |
| Pelakka Wurm | 765 |
| Painful Quandary (12 variants) | 179 |
| Pacifism (6 variants) | 501 |
| Ovika, Enigma Goliath | 663 |
| Overrun (12 variants) | 230 |
| Orzhov Guildgate | 692 |
| Ordeal of Nylea | 641 |
| Opt (6 variants) | 512 |
| Omniscience (12 variants) | 312 |
| Omniscience (12 variants) | 161 |
| Omniscience | 379 |
| Offer Immortality (6 variants) | 525 |
| Obliterating Bolt | 629 |
| Nullpriest of Oblivion | 611 |
| Niv-Mizzet, Visionary | 411 |
| Niv-Mizzet, Visionary (12 variants) | 123 |
| Niv-Mizzet, Visionary (8 variants) | 482 |
| Niv-Mizzet, Visionary (12 variants) | 350 |
| Nine-Lives Familiar (12 variants) | 66 |
| Nine-Lives Familiar (12 variants) | 321 |
| Nine-Lives Familiar | 385 |
| Nine-Lives Familiar (8 variants) | 462 |
| New Horizons (6 variants) | 557 |
| Nessian Hornbeetle (12 variants) | 229 |
| Negate | 710 |
| Needletooth Pack (12 variants) | 108 |
| Mystical Teachings | 594 |