| Jungle Hollow (12 variants) | 263 |
| Juggernaut (12 variants) | 255 |
| Joust Through (12 variants) | 19 |
| Joraga Invocation (6 variants) | 555 |
| Jazal Goldmane (6 variants) | 497 |
| Izzet Guildgate | 691 |
| Island (12 variants) | 275 |
| Island (12 variants) | 284 |
| Island (12 variants) | 285 |
| Island (12 variants) | 274 |
| Involuntary Employment (12 variants) | 203 |
| Into the Roil (6 variants) | 509 |
| Inspiring Paladin (12 variants) | 18 |
| Inspiring Overseer (6 variants) | 496 |
| Inspiring Overseer | 736 |
| Inspiring Call (12 variants) | 226 |
| Inspiration from Beyond (12 variants) | 43 |
| Ingenious Leonin (6 variants) | 495 |
| Infestation Sage (12 variants) | 64 |
| Infernal Vessel (12 variants) | 63 |
| Incinerating Blast (12 variants) | 90 |
| Imprisoned in the Moon (12 variants) | 156 |
| Imperious Perfect | 719 |
| Impact Tremors | 717 |
| Immersturm Predator | 660 |
| Icewind Elemental (12 variants) | 42 |
| Icewind Elemental | 742 |
| Hungry Ghoul (12 variants) | 62 |
| Homunculus Horde (12 variants) | 308 |
| Homunculus Horde | 376 |
| Homunculus Horde (8 variants) | 454 |
| Homunculus Horde (12 variants) | 41 |
| Hoarding Dragon | 626 |
| Hinterland Sanctifier (6 variants) | 730 |
| Highborn Vampire (6 variants) | 522 |
| High-Society Hunter (12 variants) | 61 |
| High-Society Hunter | 384 |
| High-Society Hunter (12 variants) | 320 |
| High-Society Hunter (8 variants) | 461 |
| High Fae Trickster (8 variants) | 453 |
| High Fae Trickster (12 variants) | 40 |
| High Fae Trickster | 375 |
| High Fae Trickster (12 variants) | 307 |
| Hidetsugu's Second Rite (12 variants) | 202 |
| Heroic Reinforcements (12 variants) | 241 |
| Heroes' Bane | 639 |
| Hero's Downfall (12 variants) | 319 |
| Hero's Downfall (12 variants) | 175 |
| Heraldic Banner (12 variants) | 254 |
| Herald of Faith | 735 |