| Pygmy Pyrosaur (17 variants) | 208 |
| Pygmy Pyrosaur | 208★ |
| Purify | 31★ |
| Purify (17 variants) | 31 |
| Prodigal Sorcerer | 94★ |
| Prodigal Sorcerer (17 variants) | 94 |
| Pride of Lions | 261★ |
| Pride of Lions (17 variants) | 261 |
| Plains (17 variants) | 343 |
| Plains | 341★ |
| Plains (17 variants) | 342 |
| Plains | 344★ |
| Plains (17 variants) | 344 |
| Plains | 342★ |
| Plains (17 variants) | 341 |
| Plains | 343★ |
| Plague Beetle (17 variants) | 155 |
| Plague Beetle | 155★ |
| Pit Trap | 313★ |
| Pit Trap (17 variants) | 313 |
| Pillage | 207★ |
| Pillage (17 variants) | 207 |
| Phyrexian Hulk (17 variants) | 312 |
| Phyrexian Hulk | 312★ |
| Phyrexian Colossus (17 variants) | 311 |
| Phyrexian Colossus | 311★ |
| Phantom Warrior | 93★ |
| Phantom Warrior (17 variants) | 93 |
| Persecute | 154★ |
| Persecute (17 variants) | 154 |
| Patagia Golem (17 variants) | 310 |
| Patagia Golem | 310★ |
| Pariah (17 variants) | 30 |
| Pariah | 30★ |
| Pacifism (17 variants) | 29 |
| Pacifism | 29★ |
| Ostracize | 153★ |
| Ostracize (17 variants) | 153 |
| Orcish Oriflamme (17 variants) | 206 |
| Orcish Oriflamme | 206★ |
| Orcish Artillery | 205★ |
| Orcish Artillery (17 variants) | 205 |
| Oppression (17 variants) | 152 |
| Oppression | 152★ |
| Opposition | 92★ |
| Opposition (17 variants) | 92 |
| Opportunity (17 variants) | 91 |
| Opportunity | 91★ |
| Okk | 204★ |
| Okk (17 variants) | 204 |