| Crucible of Worlds (2 variants) | 7162 |
| Crucible of Worlds (2 variants) | 2110 |
| Crypt Ghast (2 variants) | 169 |
| Cryptbreaker | 839 |
| Cryptic Command | 905 |
| Cryptolith Rite (2 variants) | 2293 |
| Crystal Spray | 2152 |
| Crystalline Sliver | 661 |
| Culling the Weak (2 variants) | 1818 |
| Culling the Weak | 883 |
| Cultivate | 2437 |
| Cultivate (2 variants) | 246 |
| Cultivate (2 variants) | 2679 |
| Cultural Exchange (2 variants) | 2071 |
| Curiosity | 403 |
| Curiosity | 2569 |
| Cursed Mirror (2 variants) | 2308 |
| Cut // Ribbons | 367 |
| Cyclonic Rift (4 variants) | 1869 |
| Dack Fayden (2 variants) | 1689 |
| Dack Fayden | 251 |
| Dakkon Blackblade (2 variants) | 698 |
| Damn (4 variants) | 1870 |
| Damnation (2 variants) | 2019 |
| Damnation (2 variants) | 121 |
| Damnation (2 variants) | 2000 |
| Dance of Many (2 variants) | 442 |
| Dance of the Manse (2 variants) | 2104 |
| Dandân | 2138 |
| Dandân | 2139 |
| Danitha Capashen, Paragon (2 variants) | 1031 |
| Daretti, Ingenious Iconoclast | 1422 |
| Daretti, Ingenious Iconoclast | 1422★ |
| Darien, King of Kjeldor | 7135 |
| Dark Deal (2 variants) | 873 |
| Dark Depths (2 variants) | 1680 |
| Dark Petition | 2525 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2001 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2020 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2665 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2678 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 1170 |
| Darksteel Citadel (2 variants) | 608 |
| Darksteel Colossus | 57 |
| Darksteel Colossus // Darksteel Colossus (2 variants) | 1081 |
| Darksteel Ingot (2 variants) | 204 |
| Darksteel Mutation | 1836 |
| Darksteel Plate (2 variants) | 1572 |
| Daryl, Hunter of Walkers | 144 |
| Dauthi Voidwalker (2 variants) | 1760 |