| Sun Titan (2 variants) | 1550 |
| Sulfuric Vortex (2 variants) | 2210 |
| Subtlety | 7005 |
| Sublime Archangel (2 variants) | 1381 |
| Stuffy Doll (2 variants) | 880 |
| Strip Mine | 472 |
| Striking Sliver | 644 |
| Strefan, Maurer Progenitor (2 variants) | 2501 |
| Stranglehold (2 variants) | 1804 |
| Storm, Force of Nature (2 variants) | 1742 |
| Storm-Kiln Artist (2 variants) | 2352 |
| Storm Crow | 60 |
| Storm Counter | 2422 |
| Stony Silence (2 variants) | 2554 |
| Stoneforge Mystic (2 variants) | 1253 |
| Stonecoil Serpent (2 variants) | 1226 |
| Stomping Ground | 126 |
| Stitcher's Supplier (2 variants) | 1098 |
| Stitcher's Supplier | 853 |
| Stitch in Time // Stitch in Time | 382 |
| Stinkweed Imp (2 variants) | 2516 |
| Stinging Study (2 variants) | 2481 |
| Stifle (2 variants) | 1787 |
| Sticker sheet (2 variants) | 337 |
| Sticker sheet (2 variants) | 338 |
| Sticker sheet (2 variants) | 335 |
| Sticker sheet (2 variants) | 336 |
| Sticker sheet (2 variants) | 339 |
| Stensia Bloodhall (2 variants) | 353 |
| Steely Resolve // Steely Resolve | 1326 |
| Steelshaper's Gift (2 variants) | 2166 |
| Steelshaper's Gift | 1632 |
| Steelshaper's Gift | 1632★ |
| Steam Vents | 129 |
| Stasis (2 variants) | 1103 |
| Stardew Valley (2 variants) | 2801 |
| Star of Extinction (4 variants) | 1862 |
| Staff of the Storyteller (4 variants) | 1863 |
| Sram, Senior Edificer (2 variants) | 461 |
| Squirrel Wrangler | 198 |
| Squirrel Mob | 197 |
| Squirrel | 200 |
| Squire | 59 |
| Spore Frog (2 variants) | 696 |
| Spiteful Sliver | 643 |
| Spiteful Prankster (2 variants) | 801 |
| Spirited Companion (2 variants) | 896 |
| Spirit of the Hearth (2 variants) | 2654 |
| Spirit Mantle (2 variants) | 2451 |
| Spirit | 1852 |