| Drown in Dreams (2 variants) | 1668 |
| Drown in the Loch (2 variants) | 1790 |
| Drown in the Loch (2 variants) | 270 |
| Drowned Catacomb (2 variants) | 457 |
| Druid of Purification | 877 |
| Dryad Arbor (2 variants) | 2281 |
| Dryad of the Ilysian Grove (2 variants) | 191 |
| Dungeon Delver (2 variants) | 7103 |
| Duress (2 variants) | 479 |
| Dustin, Gadget Genius (2 variants) | 342 |
| Duty Beyond Death (2 variants) | 2387 |
| E. Honda, Sumo Champion (2 variants) | 428 |
| Earthquake (2 variants) | 2666 |
| Ebondeath, Dracolich | 1014 |
| Echo of Eons | 821 |
| Edgin, Larcenous Lutenist (2 variants) | 1242 |
| Egg | 1398★ |
| Egg | 1398 |
| Eidolon of the Great Revel (2 variants) | 422 |
| Eiganjo Castle (2 variants) | 2230 |
| Eladamri's Call (2 variants) | 1770 |
| Eladamri's Vineyard (2 variants) | 1692 |
| Eldrazi Conscription (2 variants) | 1218 |
| Eldrazi Monument | 603 |
| Eldrazi Temple (2 variants) | 1154 |
| Eldritch Evolution (2 variants) | 1414 |
| Elenda, the Dusk Rose | 1411 |
| Elenda, the Dusk Rose | 1411★ |
| Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite | 811 |
| Eleven, the Mage (2 variants) | 343 |
| Elf Warrior | 7170 |
| Elf Warrior | 7169 |
| Elf Warrior | 7168 |
| Elixir of Immortality | 1634★ |
| Elixir of Immortality | 1634 |
| Ellie, Brick Master (2 variants) | 2197 |
| Ellie, Vengeful Hunter (2 variants) | 2203 |
| Elspeth Tirel (4 variants) | 1585 |
| Elspeth, Knight-Errant (2 variants) | 1001 |
| Elspeth, Knight-Errant (2 variants) | 701 |
| Elspeth, Sun's Champion (2 variants) | 1140 |
| Elves of Deep Shadow (2 variants) | 1710 |
| Elvish Champion | 761 |
| Elvish Mystic (2 variants) | 475 |
| Elvish Mystic (4 variants) | 805 |
| Elvish Reclaimer (2 variants) | 2015 |
| Elvish Spirit Guide (2 variants) | 423 |
| Elvish Vanguard | 762 |
| Elvish Visionary | 763 |
| Emeria, the Sky Ruin (2 variants) | 1291 |