| Shoot the Sheriff (2 variants) | 7166 |
| Shivan Dragon (2 variants) | 1709 |
| Shivan Dragon | 716 |
| Shire Terrace (2 variants) | 1296 |
| Shiny Impetus | 1845 |
| Shiny Impetus (2 variants) | 7165 |
| Sheltered Thicket (2 variants) | 2522 |
| Sheltered by Ghosts (2 variants) | 2653 |
| Shelter (2 variants) | 1587★ |
| Shelter (2 variants) | 1587 |
| Shelldock Isle (2 variants) | 437 |
| Shelldock Isle (2 variants) | 230 |
| Shattergang Brothers | 1315 |
| Shattergang Brothers | 1315★ |
| Shared Summons | 1308 |
| Shared Roots (2 variants) | 2391 |
| Shapeshifter | 1906 |
| Shapeshifter | 1907 |
| Shapeshifter | 1908 |
| Shapeshifter | 1909 |
| Shaman of the Pack | 789 |
| Shalai, Voice of Plenty (2 variants) | 244 |
| Shalai, Voice of Plenty | 2433 |
| Shadowspear (2 variants) | 1505 |
| Shadowheart, Dark Justiciar (2 variants) | 2483 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 683 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 681Φ |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 684 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 686 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 682 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 680 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 681 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 687 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 688 |
| Shadowborn Apostle | 685 |
| Shadow the Hedgehog (2 variants) | 2086 |
| Shadow Sliver | 624 |
| Shadow of Doubt (2 variants) | 414 |
| Seven Dwarves | 813 |
| Seven Dwarves | 817 |
| Seven Dwarves | 815 |
| Seven Dwarves | 819 |
| Seven Dwarves | 818 |
| Seven Dwarves | 816 |
| Seven Dwarves | 814 |
| Settle the Wreckage (2 variants) | 2372 |
| Seshiro the Anointed (2 variants) | 1224 |
| Serum Visions | 2338 |
| Serum Visions | 30 |
| Serum Visions | 32 |