| Qasali Slingers | 24 |
| Pyromancer's Goggles (2 variants) | 1066 |
| Pyrohemia (2 variants) | 2211 |
| Pyrite Spellbomb (2 variants) | 676 |
| Pyretic Ritual (2 variants) | 1064 |
| Putrefy (2 variants) | 2299 |
| Purphoros, God of the Forge | 77 |
| Puresteel Paladin (2 variants) | 1352 |
| Pulmonic Sliver | 613 |
| Puca's Mischief | 923 |
| Psychic Corrosion (2 variants) | 1669 |
| Psionic Sliver | 621 |
| Protean Hulk (2 variants) | 319 |
| Prossh, Skyraider of Kher (2 variants) | 1717 |
| Prosperous Innkeeper | 878 |
| Prosper, Tome-Bound (2 variants) | 2496 |
| Propaganda // Propaganda | 381 |
| Propaganda | 1633 |
| Propaganda | 1633★ |
| Progenitus (2 variants) | 1163 |
| Professional Face-Breaker (2 variants) | 1706 |
| Prodigal Sorcerer (2 variants) | 1672 |
| Prismatic Vista (2 variants) | 2699 |
| Prismatic Omen (2 variants) | 1104 |
| Prismatic Ending (4 variants) | 1868 |
| Prince of Thralls | 1549 |
| Prince of Thralls | 1549★ |
| Primordial Hydra | 1330 |
| Primeval Titan (2 variants) | 221 |
| Primeval Titan (2 variants) | 494 |
| Primal Vigor (2 variants) | 314 |
| Primal Vigor (2 variants) | 1749 |
| Priest of Forgotten Gods (2 variants) | 2006 |
| Pride of the Perfect (2 variants) | 7098 |
| Price of Progress | 1521 |
| Price of Progress | 1521★ |
| Price of Glory | 1525 |
| Preordain (2 variants) | 2301 |
| Preordain (2 variants) | 1719 |
| Preordain | 186 |
| Predict | 2156 |
| Predatory Sliver | 654 |
| Pre-War Formalwear (2 variants) | 2450 |
| Praetor's Grasp (2 variants) | 1023 |
| Praetor's Grasp (4 variants) | 1861 |
| Possibility Storm | 7073 |
| Pontiff of Blight | 848 |
| Ponder (2 variants) | 2670 |
| Ponder (2 variants) | 1783 |
| Ponder (2 variants) | 7125 |