| Plains (2 variants) | 46 |
| Plains | 544 |
| Plains (2 variants) | 1088 |
| Plains (2 variants) | 359 |
| Plaguecrafter (4 variants) | 1116 |
| Plague Sliver | 633Φ |
| Plague Sliver | 633 |
| Plague Engineer | 1215 |
| Pitiless Plunderer (2 variants) | 1431 |
| Pithing Needle | 44 |
| Pirated Copy (2 variants) | 2363 |
| Pir, Imaginative Rascal (2 variants) | 1050 |
| Piper of the Swarm | 7074 |
| Pinkie Pie (2 variants) | 1539 |
| Pilgrim's Eye | 692 |
| Phyrexian Unlife | 1213 |
| Phyrexian Tower (2 variants) | 208 |
| Phyrexian Reclamation (2 variants) | 1808 |
| Phyrexian Processor | 2445 |
| Phyrexian Metamorph (2 variants) | 1758 |
| Phyrexian Metamorph (4 variants) | 1110 |
| Phyrexian Crusader | 1214 |
| Phyrexian Crusader | 847 |
| Phyrexian Arena | 2333 |
| Phyrexian Arena (2 variants) | 2318 |
| Phenax, God of Deception | 75 |
| Pharika, God of Affliction | 82 |
| Phantasmal Image (2 variants) | 2306 |
| Phage the Untouchable | 1195 |
| Personal Tutor (2 variants) | 2492 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 597 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 596 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 600 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 599 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 601 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 598 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 593 |
| Persistent Petitioners | 595 |
| Pernicious Deed (2 variants) | 1777 |
| Peregrine Drake | 1488 |
| Peregrine Drake | 1488★ |
| Peer into the Abyss (2 variants) | 2021 |
| Peer into the Abyss (2 variants) | 2002 |
| Peek | 401 |
| Peacewalker Colossus // Peacewalker Colossus (2 variants) | 1966 |
| Patron Wizard (2 variants) | 1002 |
| Pathbreaker Ibex (2 variants) | 307 |
| Path to Exile (2 variants) | 477 |
| Path to Exile (2 variants) | 226 |
| Path to Exile (2 variants) | 2227 |