| Island | 551 |
| Island (2 variants) | 2510 |
| Island (2 variants) | 2077 |
| Island (2 variants) | 240 |
| Island | 889 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1653 |
| Island | 1951 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1946 |
| Island | 553 |
| Island | 555 |
| Island | 2144 |
| Island (2 variants) | 485 |
| Island (2 variants) | 466 |
| Island | 552 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1469 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1089 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1940 |
| Island | 549 |
| Island (2 variants) | 2541 |
| Island | 2146 |
| Island (2 variants) | 385 |
| Island | 2147 |
| Island (2 variants) | 103 |
| Island (2 variants) | 1479 |
| Island | 2145 |
| Isolated Chapel (2 variants) | 739 |
| Isshin, Two Heavens as One (2 variants) | 2459 |
| It That Betrays (2 variants) | 1176 |
| It That Betrays (2 variants) | 2673 |
| Ivy Lane Denizen | 769 |
| Iymrith, Desert Doom | 1013 |
| Izzet Signet (2 variants) | 293 |
| Jace Beleren // Jace Beleren | 746 |
| Jace Beleren // Jace Beleren (2 variants) | 1454 |
| Jace, the Mind Sculptor (2 variants) | 8001 |
| Jace, Unraveler of Secrets (4 variants) | 1590 |
| Jace, Wielder of Mysteries | 506 |
| Jace, Wielder of Mysteries | 1576 |
| Jace, Wielder of Mysteries | 1576★ |
| Jace's Archivist (2 variants) | 2515 |
| Jaspera Sentinel | 770 |
| Jaws, Relentless Predator (2 variants) | 2175 |
| Jaxis, the Troublemaker (2 variants) | 1703 |
| Jaya Ballard (2 variants) | 1062 |
| Jaya, Venerated Firemage | 513 |
| Jaya's Immolating Inferno (2 variants) | 1063 |
| Jeska, Thrice Reborn (2 variants) | 1201 |
| Jeska's Will (2 variants) | 1744 |
| Jet Medallion (2 variants) | 1189 |
| Jetmir, Nexus of Revels // Jetmir, Nexus of Revels | 1509 |