| Defile (2 variants) | 1793 |
| Defense of the Heart (2 variants) | 2537 |
| Defense of the Heart (2 variants) | 1039 |
| Deepglow Skate (2 variants) | 1093 |
| Deepglow Skate (2 variants) | 2362 |
| Decree of Pain | 187 |
| Decimate | 140 |
| Deathrite Shaman (2 variants) | 170 |
| Deathrender (2 variants) | 1573 |
| Death's Shadow (2 variants) | 474 |
| Death Baron // Death Baron (2 variants) | 1458 |
| Deafening Silence (2 variants) | 1219 |
| Deadpool, Trading Card | 7129 |
| Deadpool, Trading Card (2 variants) | 7127 |
| Deadpool, Trading Card (2 variants) | 1753 |
| Deadly Rollick (2 variants) | 1754 |
| Deadly Dispute (2 variants) | IFIYW-1 |
| Deadly Dispute (2 variants) | 2091 |
| Deadly Dispute (2 variants) | 1980 |
| Deadly Dispute | IFIYW-6 |
| Deadly Dispute (2 variants) | 1985 |
| Deadeye Navigator | 902 |
| Daze (2 variants) | 1934 |
| Day's Undoing | 2153 |
| Day of Judgment (4 variants) | 1858 |
| Dawnbreak Reclaimer | 1346 |
| Dawn's Truce (2 variants) | 2803 |
| Davriel, Rogue Shadowmage | 509 |
| Dauthi Voidwalker (2 variants) | 1760 |
| Daryl, Hunter of Walkers | 144 |
| Darksteel Plate (2 variants) | 1572 |
| Darksteel Mutation | 1836 |
| Darksteel Ingot (2 variants) | 204 |
| Darksteel Colossus // Darksteel Colossus (2 variants) | 1081 |
| Darksteel Colossus | 57 |
| Darksteel Citadel (2 variants) | 608 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2001 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2020 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2665 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 2678 |
| Dark Ritual (2 variants) | 1170 |
| Dark Petition | 2525 |
| Dark Depths (2 variants) | 1680 |
| Dark Deal (2 variants) | 873 |
| Darien, King of Kjeldor | 7135 |
| Daretti, Ingenious Iconoclast | 1422 |
| Daretti, Ingenious Iconoclast | 1422★ |
| Danitha Capashen, Paragon (2 variants) | 1031 |
| Dandân | 2138 |
| Dandân | 2139 |