| Whispersilk Cloak (2 variants) | 1574 |
| Wild Growth (2 variants) | 7049 |
| Wild-Magic Sorcerer (2 variants) | 2494 |
| Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver | 862 |
| Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver (2 variants) | 2285 |
| Will the Wise (2 variants) | 347 |
| Windborn Muse (2 variants) | 2687 |
| Windbrisk Heights (2 variants) | 436 |
| Windfall | 2571 |
| Windfall (2 variants) | 2182 |
| Windfall (2 variants) | 1775 |
| Winding Constrictor (2 variants) | 309 |
| Winds of Abandon (2 variants) | 1817 |
| Winds of Abandon | 882 |
| Winds of Change (2 variants) | 1128 |
| Winged Sliver | 628 |
| Winter Orb | 1486 |
| Winter Orb | 1486★ |
| Winter Orb | 2400 |
| Wirewood Symbiote | 785 |
| Witch Enchanter // Witch-Blessed Meadow (2 variants) | 2655 |
| Witch of the Moors (2 variants) | 1722 |
| Witch's Oven (2 variants) | 1762 |
| Wolf (2 variants) | 1613 |
| Wolverine, Best There Is (2 variants) | 1737 |
| Wood Elves (2 variants) | 2280 |
| Wood Elves (2 variants) | 1101 |
| Woodland Cemetery (2 variants) | 738 |
| World at War (2 variants) | 2208 |
| World Shaper (2 variants) | 2017 |
| Worldspine Wurm (2 variants) | 1305 |
| Worst Fears | 2398 |
| Wrath of God (2 variants) | 441 |
| Wrath of God | 185 |
| Wrexial, the Risen Deep | 584 |
| Wurm (2 variants) | 1306 |
| Wurmcoil Engine (2 variants) | 2196 |
| Wurmcoil Engine (2 variants) | 1661 |
| Xanathar, Guild Kingpin (2 variants) | 1785 |
| Xantcha, Sleeper Agent | 1271 |
| Xenagos, God of Revels (4 variants) | 2061 |
| Xenagos, God of Revels | 81 |
| Xenk, Paladin Unbroken (2 variants) | 1237 |
| Xorn | 876 |
| Xorn (2 variants) | 2495 |
| Yargle and Multani (2 variants) | 872 |
| Yargle, Glutton of Urborg // Yargle, Glutton of Urborg (2 variants) | 1542 |
| Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth (2 variants) | 2813 |
| Yeva, Nature's Herald (2 variants) | 1284 |
| Yidris, Maelstrom Wielder | 455 |