| Captain Lannery Storm | 1409 |
| Captain N'ghathrod (2 variants) | 2183 |
| Captain Sisay | 51 |
| Captain Sisay (2 variants) | 1913 |
| Capture of Jingzhou | 2149 |
| Careful Study (2 variants) | 1768 |
| Carnage Tyrant (2 variants) | 1174 |
| Carpet of Flowers (2 variants) | 279 |
| Carrion Feeder (4 variants) | 1114 |
| Cat | 1517 |
| Cat | 28 |
| Cat | 27 |
| Cathartic Reunion | 1465★ |
| Cathartic Reunion | 1465 |
| Cathartic Reunion (2 variants) | 7045 |
| Cauldron Familiar (2 variants) | 1759 |
| Chain Lightning | 2052 |
| Chain Lightning (2 variants) | 2047 |
| Chain Lightning (2 variants) | 370 |
| Chain of Vapor (2 variants) | 2295 |
| Chain Reaction (2 variants) | 2219 |
| Champion of Lambholt (4 variants) | 2245 |
| Champion of the Perished | 837 |
| Chance for Glory (2 variants) | 2470 |
| Chandra Nalaar // Chandra Nalaar | 748 |
| Chandra Nalaar // Chandra Nalaar (2 variants) | 1456 |
| Chandra, Fire Artisan | 512 |
| Chandra, Flame's Catalyst | 1420 |
| Chandra, Flame's Catalyst | 1420★ |
| Chandra, Flamecaller (4 variants) | 807 |
| Chandra's Ignition (2 variants) | 1594★ |
| Chandra's Ignition (2 variants) | 1594 |
| Changeling Outcast | 894 |
| Chaos Warp | 823 |
| Chaos Warp (2 variants) | 2692 |
| Chaos Warp | 741★ |
| Chaos Warp | 741 |
| Chaotic Goo (2 variants) | 1658 |
| Charix, the Raging Isle (2 variants) | 1927 |
| Chart a Course | 2150 |
| Chatter of the Squirrel | 195 |
| Chief Jim Hopper (2 variants) | 341 |
| Child of Alara (4 variants) | 1599 |
| Chord of Calling (4 variants) | 1595 |
| Chord of Calling (2 variants) | 2376 |
| Chromatic Lantern (2 variants) | 202 |
| Chromatic Lantern (2 variants) | 2314 |
| Chromatic Lantern | 2329 |
| Chromium | 1068 |
| Chulane, Teller of Tales // Chulane, Teller of Tales (2 variants) | 1875 |