| Power Level Analyzer | UA05c |
| Praetorhoof Behemoth | RG06a |
| Primetime Suspect | UG02a |
| Princess Snowfall | RZ04e |
| Pulse of the Hunter Maze | RG03c |
| Quest Compleated Beast | RB04d |
| Questing Cosplayer | RG02d |
| Rafi, Retro Racer | RR04e |
| Rampant, Growth | UG12 |
| Rankle, Master of Pranksters | RB04e |
| Ransack, the Lab | UB16 |
| Rat of God | RB05d |
| Ratatwotwo | RW03c |
| Really Charming Prince | RU02d |
| Red and Black Legac | UZ02 |
| Red Priest of Yawgmoth | UR02b |
| Reflective Gate | UL03a |
| Retto, Family Racer | RG02 |
| Reverse Ninja | CB02 |
| Rideable Mantis | UW03a |
| Riku and Riku | RZ04f |
| Ring Out | UU02b |
| Rinta, Cousin of Sitka | RU04 |
| Riven Turnbull and Princess Lucrezia | RZ08c |
| Rosewater's Nemesis | UW05 |
| Saga of Krark Losing His Thumb | RZ05m |
| Sagrada Familiar | UA03d |
| Save Point | RW02d |
| Sawtooth Avenger | UA06b |
| Second Stage of Magic Design | RU03d |
| Seer of the Bright Side | RB02 |
| Segovian Sword | UA03e |
| Seventh Stage of Magic Design | RZ06d |
| Shadowmoor Draw Spell | CU04b |
| Shahrazad and Sindbad | RZ04g |
| Sharp Eraser | RA06d |
| Shedding Snake | CB05 |
| Shen, Wish Granter | RZ04q |
| Sheoldred's Terror | UB12 |
| Simic Slaw | CAb |
| Simic, Value Engine | RZ08d |
| Sixth Stage of Magic Design | RW03h |
| Slobad, Actually Just Fine | RZ03a |
| Snapsail Rider | RR05 |
| Sojourner's Enforcermite | CA06b |
| Sort of _____ and _____ | RA13 |
| Soul Drainer | UB06 |
| Soul of Mirrodin | RA06b |
| Spare Changeling | CZ02 |
| Spice Rack | RA02d |