| Phalanx Leader (22 variants) | 26 |
| Pharika's Cure (22 variants) | 100 |
| Pharika's Mender (22 variants) | 197 |
| Pheres-Band Centaurs (22 variants) | 171 |
| Plains (22 variants) | 231 |
| Plains (22 variants) | 232 |
| Plains (22 variants) | 230 |
| Plains (22 variants) | 233 |
| Polis Crusher (22 variants) | 198 |
| Polukranos, World Eater (22 variants) | 172 |
| Portent of Betrayal (22 variants) | 133 |
| Prescient Chimera (22 variants) | 59 |
| Priest of Iroas (22 variants) | 134 |
| Prognostic Sphinx (22 variants) | 60 |
| Prophet of Kruphix (22 variants) | 199 |
| Prowler's Helm (22 variants) | 219 |
| Psychic Intrusion (22 variants) | 200 |
| Purphoros, God of the Forge (22 variants) | 135 |
| Purphoros's Emissary (22 variants) | 136 |
| Pyxis of Pandemonium (22 variants) | 220 |
| Rage of Purphoros (22 variants) | 137 |
| Rageblood Shaman (22 variants) | 138 |
| Ray of Dissolution (22 variants) | 27 |
| Read the Bones (22 variants) | 101 |
| Reaper of the Wilds (22 variants) | 201 |
| Rescue from the Underworld (22 variants) | 102 |
| Returned Centaur (22 variants) | 103 |
| Returned Phalanx (22 variants) | 104 |
| Reverent Hunter (22 variants) | 173 |
| Satyr Hedonist (22 variants) | 174 |
| Satyr Piper (22 variants) | 175 |
| Satyr Rambler (22 variants) | 139 |
| Savage Surge (22 variants) | 176 |
| Scholar of Athreos (22 variants) | 28 |
| Scourgemark (22 variants) | 105 |
| Sea God's Revenge (22 variants) | 61 |
| Sealock Monster (22 variants) | 62 |
| Sedge Scorpion (22 variants) | 177 |
| Sentry of the Underworld (22 variants) | 202 |
| Setessan Battle Priest (22 variants) | 29 |
| Setessan Griffin (22 variants) | 30 |
| Shipbreaker Kraken (22 variants) | 63 |
| Shipwreck Singer (22 variants) | 203 |
| Shredding Winds (22 variants) | 178 |
| Silent Artisan (22 variants) | 31 |
| Sip of Hemlock (22 variants) | 106 |
| Soldier of the Pantheon (22 variants) | 32 |
| Spark Jolt (22 variants) | 140 |
| Spear of Heliod (22 variants) | 33 |
| Spearpoint Oread (22 variants) | 141 |