| Pelakka Wurm | MM2-154 |
| Pegasus Stampede | EXO-14 |
| Pegasus Guardian // Rescue the Foal | CLB-36 |
| Pegasus Courser | M19-32 |
| Peer into the Abyss | M21-117 |
| Peema Outrider | KLD-166 |
| Peel from Reality | DDO-40 |
| Pedantic Learning | ODY-90 |
| Peat Bog | MMQ-322 |
| Pearl Shard | MRD-225 |
| Pearl Medallion | TMP-300 |
| Peace Strider | BBD-243 |
| Peace of Mind | EMN-36 |
| Pawn of Ulamog | ROE-122 |
| Patron Wizard | ODY-89 |
| Patron of the Moon (2 variants) | BOK-45 |
| Patron of the Akki | BOK-115 |
| Patriar's Seal | CLB-332 |
| Pathrazer of Ulamog | ROE-9 |
| Path to the World Tree | KHM-186 |
| Path to Exile | E02-3 |
| Path to Exile | CON-15 |
| Path of Peace | A25-29 |
| Path of Discovery | RIX-142 |
| Path of Ancestry | M3C-363 |
| Path of Ancestry | NCC-419 |
| Path of Ancestry | C17-56 |
| Path of Ancestry | CMR-353 |
| Patchwork Automaton | NEO-254 |
| Patagia Viper | DIS-89 |
| Past in Flames | MM3-105 |
| Part the Waterveil | BFZ-80 |
| Pariah's Shield | RAV-267 |
| Pariah | 10E-33 |
| Pardic Collaborator | TOR-106 |
| Parcelbeast | IKO-304 |
| Parallel Evolution | TOR-136 |
| Parallax Wave | NEM-17 |
| Paragon of Open Graves | M15-111 |
| Paradox Haze | TSP-71 |
| Paradise Mantle | MMA-211 |
| Panharmonicon | KLD-226 |
| Panglacial Wurm (2 variants) | CSP-116 |
| Pandemonium | TPR-149 |
| Pandemonium | EXO-93 |
| Palladium Myr | CM2-207 |
| Paladin of the Bloodstained | XLN-25 |
| Paladin en-Vec | 10E-32 |
| Palace Sentinels | CN2-19 |
| Palace Jailer | CN2-18 |