| Path to the World Tree | KHM-186 |
| Pathrazer of Ulamog | ROE-9 |
| Patriar's Seal | CLB-332 |
| Patron of the Akki | BOK-115 |
| Patron of the Moon (2 variants) | BOK-45 |
| Patron Wizard | ODY-89 |
| Pawn of Ulamog | ROE-122 |
| Peace of Mind | EMN-36 |
| Peace Strider | BBD-243 |
| Pearl Medallion | TMP-300 |
| Pearl Shard | MRD-225 |
| Peat Bog | MMQ-322 |
| Pedantic Learning | ODY-90 |
| Peel from Reality | DDO-40 |
| Peema Outrider | KLD-166 |
| Peer into the Abyss | M21-117 |
| Pegasus Courser | M19-32 |
| Pegasus Guardian // Rescue the Foal | CLB-36 |
| Pegasus Stampede | EXO-14 |
| Pelakka Wurm | MM2-154 |
| Pemmin's Aura | SCG-45 |
| Pendrell Drake | USG-86 |
| Pentarch Paladin | TSP-32 |
| Pentarch Ward | IMA-27 |
| Pentavus | C14-261 |
| Penumbra Kavu | APC-83 |
| Penumbra Spider | MM3-131 |
| Penumbra Wurm | UMA-177 |
| Peregrine Drake | USG-88 |
| Perilous Myr | A25-227 |
| Perilous Research | MMA-58 |
| Perimeter Captain | WWK-16 |
| Perish | TMP-147 |
| Pernicious Deed | A25-212 |
| Perpetual Timepiece | KLD-227 |
| Pest | TSTX-5 |
| Pestilence | USG-147 |
| Petrified Field | ODY-323 |
| Phabine, Boss's Confidant | NCC-9 |
| Phantasmal Bear | A25-69 |
| Phantasmal Dragon | DDM-14 |
| Phantom Centaur | JUD-127† |
| Phantom Centaur | JUD-127 |
| Phantom Flock | JUD-16 |
| Phantom Tiger | JUD-129 |
| Pharika's Libation | THB-111 |
| Phenax, God of Deception | BNG-152 |
| Phyresis | MBS-49 |
| Phyrexian Altar | UMA-232 |
| Phyrexian Arena | CN2-144 |