| Pitiless Plunderer (6 variants) | 476 |
| Plagon, Lord of the Beach (6 variants) | 37 |
| Plains (6 variants) | 81 |
| Plains (6 variants) | 82 |
| Plains (6 variants) | 83 |
| Plate Armor (6 variants) | 100 |
| Play with Fire (6 variants) | 586 |
| Pol Jamaar, Illusionist (6 variants) | 38 |
| Powerstone Fracture (6 variants) | 477 |
| Predator's Strike (6 variants) | 699 |
| Pridemalkin (6 variants) | 700 |
| Priest of Forgotten Gods (6 variants) | 478 |
| Priest of Gix (6 variants) | 121 |
| Primeval Bounty (6 variants) | 701 |
| Primeval Herald (6 variants) | 702 |
| Prophetic Prism (6 variants) | 758 |
| Prosperous Thief (6 variants) | 346 |
| Psemilla, Meletian Poet (6 variants) | 31 |
| Purple-Crystal Crab (6 variants) | 347 |
| Pyrophobia (6 variants) | 587 |
| Qala, Ajani's Pridemate (6 variants) | 32 |
| Quirion Beastcaller (6 variants) | 703 |
| Raise the Alarm (6 variants) | 101 |
| Rally of Wings (6 variants) | 238 |
| Rampant Growth (6 variants) | 704 |
| Rapacious Dragon (6 variants) | 588 |
| Razorgrass Invoker (6 variants) | 22 |
| Read the Bones (6 variants) | 479 |
| Realm Seekers (6 variants) | 705 |
| Reaper from the Abyss (6 variants) | 480 |
| Reassembling Skeleton (6 variants) | 481 |
| Reckless Amplimancer (6 variants) | 706 |
| Reckless Impulse (6 variants) | 589 |
| Reckless Scholar (6 variants) | 348 |
| Recruitment Officer (6 variants) | 239 |
| Recumbent Bliss (6 variants) | 240 |
| Relic Axe (6 variants) | 759 |
| Relief Captain (6 variants) | 241 |
| Remand (6 variants) | 349 |
| Renegade Tactics (6 variants) | 590 |
| Repel the Darkness (6 variants) | 242 |
| Resistance Reunited (6 variants) | 243 |
| Resistance Skywarden (6 variants) | 591 |
| Retreat to Kazandu (6 variants) | 707 |
| Rev, Tithe Extractor (6 variants) | 45 |
| Revitalize (6 variants) | 244 |
| Revoke Demise (6 variants) | 10 |
| Rhox Faithmender (6 variants) | 245 |
| Righteous Valkyrie (6 variants) | 246 |
| Rionya, Fire Dancer (6 variants) | 75 |