| Question Elemental? | 43★ |
| Pygmy Giant (2 variants) | 85 |
| Punctuate (2 variants) | 84 |
| Pointy Finger of Doom (2 variants) | 126 |
| Plains (2 variants) | 136 |
| Phyrexian Librarian (2 variants) | 62 |
| Persecute Artist (2 variants) | 61 |
| Our Market Research Shows That Players Like Really Long Card Names So We Made this Card to Have the Absolute Longest Card Name Ever Elemental (2 variants) | 107 |
| Orcish Paratroopers (2 variants) | 83 |
| Old Fogey | 106 |
| Old Fogey | 106★ |
| Number Crunch (2 variants) | 42 |
| Now I Know My ABC's (2 variants) | 41 |
| Necro-Impotence (2 variants) | 60 |
| Name Dropping (2 variants) | 105 |
| My First Tome | 125★ |
| My First Tome | 125 |
| Mox Lotus | 124★ |
| Mox Lotus | 124 |
| Mouth to Mouth (2 variants) | 40 |
| Mountain (2 variants) | 139 |
| Mother of Goons (2 variants) | 59 |
| Mons's Goblin Waiters | 82 |
| Mons's Goblin Waiters | 82★ |
| Monkey Monkey Monkey | 104★ |
| Monkey Monkey Monkey | 104 |
| Moniker Mage (2 variants) | 39 |
| Mise (2 variants) | 38 |
| Meddling Kids (2 variants) | 118 |
| Mana Screw | 123 |
| Mana Screw | 123★ |
| Mana Flair (2 variants) | 81 |
| Man of Measure (2 variants) | 18 |
| Magical Hacker (2 variants) | 37 |
| Loose Lips (2 variants) | 36 |
| Look at Me, I'm R&D (2 variants) | 17 |
| Little Girl (2 variants) | 16 |
| Letter Bomb | 122★ |
| Letter Bomb | 122 |
| Laughing Hyena | 103★ |
| Laughing Hyena | 103 |
| Land Aid '04 (2 variants) | 102 |
| Ladies' Knight (2 variants) | 15 |
| Kill! Destroy! (2 variants) | 58 |
| Keeper of the Sacred Word | 101★ |
| Keeper of the Sacred Word | 101 |
| Johnny, Combo Player (2 variants) | 35 |
| Island (2 variants) | 137 |
| Infernal Spawn of Infernal Spawn of Evil (2 variants) | 57 |
| Head to Head (2 variants) | 14 |