| Kill! Destroy! (2 variants) | 58 |
| Infernal Spawn of Infernal Spawn of Evil (2 variants) | 57 |
| Farewell to Arms | 56★ |
| Farewell to Arms | 56 |
| The Fallen Apart (2 variants) | 55 |
| Eye to Eye (2 variants) | 54 |
| Enter the Dungeon (2 variants) | 53 |
| Duh (2 variants) | 52 |
| Booster Tutor (2 variants) | 51 |
| Bloodletter (2 variants) | 50 |
| Bad Ass | 49★ |
| Bad Ass | 49 |
| Aesthetic Consultation | 48★ |
| Aesthetic Consultation | 48 |
| Topsy Turvy (2 variants) | 47 |
| Spell Counter (2 variants) | 46 |
| Smart Ass (2 variants) | 45 |
| Richard Garfield, Ph.D. | 44★ |
| Richard Garfield, Ph.D. | 44 |
| Question Elemental? | 43★ |
| Question Elemental? | 43 |
| Number Crunch (2 variants) | 42 |
| Now I Know My ABC's (2 variants) | 41 |
| Mouth to Mouth (2 variants) | 40 |
| Moniker Mage (2 variants) | 39 |
| Mise (2 variants) | 38 |
| Magical Hacker (2 variants) | 37 |
| Loose Lips (2 variants) | 36 |
| Johnny, Combo Player (2 variants) | 35 |
| Greater Morphling | 34★ |
| Greater Morphling | 34 |
| Framed! (2 variants) | 33 |
| Flaccify (2 variants) | 32 |
| Double Header (2 variants) | 31 |
| Cheatyface (2 variants) | 30 |
| Carnivorous Death-Parrot (2 variants) | 29 |
| Bursting Beebles (2 variants) | 28 |
| Brushstroke Paintermage (2 variants) | 27 |
| Avatar of Me (2 variants) | 26 |
| Artful Looter (2 variants) | 25 |
| Ambiguity (2 variants) | 24 |
| _____ (2 variants) | 23 |
| Wordmail (2 variants) | 22 |
| Staying Power (2 variants) | 21 |
| Standing Army | 20★ |
| Standing Army | 20 |
| Save Life (2 variants) | 19 |
| Man of Measure (2 variants) | 18 |
| Look at Me, I'm R&D (2 variants) | 17 |
| Little Girl (2 variants) | 16 |