| Johnny, Combo Player | 23 |
| Jack-in-the-Mox | 78 |
| Island (2 variants) | 90 |
| Island | 89 |
| Inhumaniac | 41 |
| Infinity Elemental | 54 |
| Infernius Spawnington III, Esq. | 40 |
| Infernal Spawn of Infernal Spawn of Evil | 39 |
| Infernal Spawn of Evil | 38 |
| Humming- | 7 |
| Hoisted Hireling | 37 |
| Half-Squirrel, Half- | 65 |
| Growth Spurt | 64 |
| Goblin Tutor | 53 |
| Goblin S.W.A.T. Team | 52 |
| Goblin Haberdasher | 51 |
| GO TO JAIL | 6 |
| Free-Range Chicken | 63 |
| Frankie Peanuts | 5 |
| Forest | 95 |
| Forest (2 variants) | 96 |
| Flavor Judge | 4 |
| Entirely Normal Armchair | 77 |
| Enter the Dungeon | 36 |
| Emcee | 3 |
| Elvish Impersonators | 62 |
| Duh | 35 |
| Dirty Rat | 34 |
| Common Iguana | 50 |
| Common Courtesy | 22 |
| Chicken à la King | 21 |
| Cheatyface | 20 |
| Carnivorous Death-Parrot | 19 |
| Bronze Calendar | 76 |
| Booster Tutor | 33 |
| Boomstacker | 49 |
| Blast from the Past | 48 |
| Bat- | 32 |
| B.O.B. (Bevy of Beebles) | 18 |
| B-I-N-G-O | 61 |
| AWOL | 2 |
| Avatar of Me | 17 |
| Alexander Clamilton | 16 |
| Adorable Kitten | 1 |
| Acornelia, Fashionable Filcher | 31 |
| Abstract Iguanart | 47 |