| Phyrexian Revoker (10 variants) | 282 |
| Plains (2 variants) | 373 |
| Plains (2 variants) | 374 |
| Pongify (10 variants) | 62 |
| Progenitor Mimic (10 variants) | 212 |
| Puresteel Paladin (10 variants) | 26 |
| Pyrewild Shaman (10 variants) | 138 |
| Pyrite Spellbomb (10 variants) | 283 |
| Rage Reflection (10 variants) | 139 |
| Rapacious Dragon (10 variants) | 140 |
| Ratchet Bomb (10 variants) | 284 |
| Ravenous Intruder (10 variants) | 141 |
| Ravenous Trap (10 variants) | 103 |
| Reclamation Sage (10 variants) | 178 |
| Relic Runner (10 variants) | 63 |
| Remember the Fallen (10 variants) | 27 |
| Reshape (10 variants) | 64 |
| Revoke Existence (10 variants) | 28 |
| Rhys the Redeemed (10 variants) | 213 |
| Riddlesmith (10 variants) | 65 |
| Riku of Two Reflections (10 variants) | 214 |
| Rolling Earthquake (10 variants) | 142 |
| Rugged Prairie (10 variants) | 325 |
| Rush of Knowledge (10 variants) | 66 |
| Salivating Gremlins (10 variants) | 143 |
| Salvage Titan (10 variants) | 104 |
| Sanctum Gargoyle (10 variants) | 29 |
| Sanctum Spirit (10 variants) | 30 |
| Sandstone Oracle (10 variants) | 285 |
| Savageborn Hydra (10 variants) | 215 |
| Sculpting Steel (10 variants) | 286 |
| Selesnya Guildmage (10 variants) | 217 |
| Sen Triplets (10 variants) | 218 |
| Sentinel of the Pearl Trident (10 variants) | 67 |
| Serra Sphinx (10 variants) | 68 |
| Shamanic Revelation (10 variants) | 179 |
| Sharuum the Hegemon (10 variants) | 219 |
| Sickleslicer (10 variants) | 287 |
| Sift (10 variants) | 69 |
| Silumgar Scavenger (10 variants) | 105 |
| Skinbrand Goblin (10 variants) | 144 |
| Skinwing (10 variants) | 288 |
| Skirsdag High Priest (10 variants) | 106 |
| Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon (10 variants) | 107 |
| Skullmulcher (10 variants) | 180 |
| Sneak Attack (10 variants) | 145 |
| Sneak Attack (2 variants) | 348 |
| Spellskite (10 variants) | 289 |
| Sphinx of the Guildpact (10 variants) | 290 |
| Sphinx Summoner (10 variants) | 220 |